Assalamualaikum and good morning again everyone.
Raya is approaching soon as I said in my earlier post. Yesterday you reviewed a short video...good to read all the responses you have written. Congratulations and well done everyone. You have made good and excellent reviews. Today I am sharing another short video, a much sadder and more deeply heart-touching one, I could say. My tears dropped every time I watched this video. There are a lot of things to learn from it.
Share your feelings and how they touched your hearts. What are the lessons you learned from the scenes shown in the video? Would love to read each and every one of your writings. Do share.
Much love
Madam Mas
54 comments:
The short film tells me about the importance of appreciating the whole family, especially on Eid day. We should apologize to each other to foster a happy family and spend quality time together. Avoid heating up arguments to prevent misunderstandings within the family. Show love to all family members so that the memories will always stay with us, and we’ll miss recapping them. Also, help each other hang out with them. Happy Eid to everyone, sincerely from me!
What I understand about the situation in this video is that Helmi is a mischievous, evil type of person who likes to steal things from villagers until one village claims that he likes to steal people's things. That's what his mother treats Helmi firmly and harshly compared to other siblings, more gentle and caring. But when Helmi has been slow to improve and become better until he can become a supervisor, his mother still scolds him because his previous behavior was naughty. Although far away in the corner of her heart, she still loves him and hopes that things will get better.
That's the one who always prays, but her mother's mistake is that she doesn't show her love and concern for Helmi until Helmi holds a grudge against her mother. It's just that when his brother comes to tell the truth, it's too late, until at some point he can't feel his mother's love in reality and face to face. The lesson is, it doesn't matter if it's a parent or a child, as long as you have the opportunity to love, do it. Don't feel regret if they are
So as child, we have to always love and apperciate them because they are very important to us
Family is very important when it comes to Raya (Eid) in Malay culture. During Raya, we normally seek for forgiveness from one another.. especially from our parents and family members.
So crucial that we usually dedicate an hour in the morning of the 1st day of Eid to ask for forgiveness from our family members in the most sincere way possible..this whole process normally will be very emotional as it involves exchange of emotions and tears. Its a time for us to forgive and forget and strengthen our relationships.
As such, in this video the guy is having regrets and remorse for not being able to do that with his mother, no matter what the feeling or past experience..family is always family.
And its also a custom to visit the grave of our loved ones during Eid.
P/s: 1 too, miss my beloved
( MUHAMMAD FAHREN AIMIN BIN AZMAN FROM B5T5 )
What I understand about the situation in this video is that Helmi is a mischievous, evil type of person who likes to steal things from villagers until one village claims that he likes to steal people's things. That's what his mother treats Helmi firmly and harshly compared to other siblings, more gentle and caring. But when Helmi has been slow to improve and become better until he can become a supervisor, his mother still scolds him because his previous behavior was naughty. Although far away in the corner of her heart, she still loves him and hopes that things will get better.
That's the one who always prays, but her mother's mistake is that she doesn't show her love and concern for Helmi until Helmi holds a grudge against her mother. It's just that when his brother comes to tell the truth, it's too late, until at some point he can't feel his mother's love in reality and face to face. The lesson is, it doesn't matter if it's a parent or a child, as long as you have the opportunity to love, do it. Don't feel regret if they are
So as child, we have to always love and apperciate them because they are very important to us
What a heartbreaking story...Well during Eid people usually ask for forgiveness for what sin they done to people and also grave pilgrimage for family members that already pass away..So this story show a son who was missing his mother that has pass away long ago...He also uncover the thruth of his mother behaviour for him that he's very felt unfair..Well we can see how the plot really heart touching when his brother tell the true story to him..So moral of the story is we should ask forgiveness for whatever sin we have done, we also should love our family as we love ourselves, dont judge other blindly because it will make us disgusting..
So that's all from me..
(Akif-b5t5)
From the story i can say family is important even though we have everything.other than that i can say that this short film tell me we need to always Grateful about everything that we have because it not mean to be forever such as , parents ,siblings and so on. It's things that can be replaced, can't buy and can't even though you have a ton of money.last but not least the thing that we can is "don't judge book by is cover" . Because like in the movie the son doesn't see what her mom doing behind him,thing that he just that her mother doesn't care about him but the reality her mom just doesn't want to show her kindness to her kid .In conclusion i think that movie have give a lot of lessons even though the movie a clishe but it's really give an impact to us to see what we don't see.
After I watched the film, Im feeling very sad because its all about family. The main character want his mother to be proud of him. He made everything to get his mother's attention. Unfortunately, his mother not express her feeling but keep it secret. The main character was mad and thought that her mother didnt love him. Finally, his oldest brother reveal the secret that their mother vey proud of him and always prayed protection for him. " orang nak peluk mak sekejap pun jadi laa " a sentence that very touch my heart
(Firdaus B5T5)
From the Tak Pernah Suka Mak shortfilm i watched, i got that we need to be balance on the things we do. The ads want to show that a child who married, need to be fair on spending their time on works and family. It also shows me that mother is a person that will always love and forgive their child even though their child are always busy on works.
This shortfilm really touch my heart on the climax. His mother was died on the first eid. Then mak kiah who always taking care of his mother came to tell him that his mother always forgive him everyday.
This shortfilm did make my heart break when his wife ask for his forgiveness because she always pressuring him without knowing his problem that he keep from everyone.
I hope this shortfilm will go further in the future.
(Aqil Imtiyaz bin Muhamad Fuzi class B5T5)
I love this short film because all the actors play their characteristics in all situations. One of part that touched my heart is Beto's mom show her love and give hug to her son when he's sleeping but Beto didnt know about that until his brother,Sharnaz told him about truth situation when his mom was died.Beside that,since Beto was child he didnt get separation of love equally from his mom and he always have caned by his mother.When Beto back home,his mother was very unspoken and ignored what her son said to her.An example,Beto have told her mom that he became a schools prefect but his mom didnt react to him.
the moral values from this film is mercy and love are very important in our live especially in our family.The parent should show their love and Happiness expression onto childs instead ignore their childs for each time.
My comment conveyed in the video emphasizes the importance of reciprocal love and respect within families, particularly from parents towards their children. While it's essential for children to respect their parents, the video highlights the crucial role parents play in demonstrating love and appreciation towards their children, regardless of their achievements or challenges.
The speaker advocates against favoritism towards successful children and encourages parents to acknowledge and support all their children equally. They underscore the significance of nurturing the emotional well-being of each child, even if it means apologizing for past mistakes or oversights.
Furthermore, the video underscores the idea that children also experience sadness and empathy when parents show vulnerability and apologize. It urges parents not to be overly focused on their own authority but to prioritize understanding and caring for their children's hearts, recognizing that they are the future torchbearers of the family lineage.
Overall, the video serves as a poignant reminder for parents to foster a loving and supportive environment within the family, emphasizing mutual understanding and respect between generations.
SYARMIN M4T4
Short film Tak Pernah Suka Mak I do learn
Mother's love is not always the same with other siblings. Sometimes kids don't understand why mother show her love differently to her children.
For my personal points mother should not show her love differently to her children with excuses I love all of my kids in my heart. Kids need to raise by love and action.
Kids will assumed mother doesn't love them because some reason. So all negative though as saying Iam a useless child will hunting them until the end of their life because the action will turn to their trauma and as mother that will be the last thing will happen.
Iman M4T4
This short film tells about Beto who think his mom don’t like him. I especially sad to see that his mother doesn’t love or care about him. I think mom highlights her love so that her son thinks she hates him, so that her son will study and succeed more diligently. She is proud that she was able to know that her son was successful from that incident, but she didn't know that she didn't have time to tell her son what she did because she wanted to make her son more focused on being successful. Sometimes unexpected things happen in life so we don't know what to do. Only then can we learn from mistakes. This movie is a have many good lesson to applied to our daily life.
ARIFF KAMIL (M4T4)
From the shortfilm 'Tak Pernah Suka Mak' i understand the important of love and affection from parent towards their children. When the parents neglected their child, it can affect the behaviour, emotion and health.
Second thing that i learned from the shortfilm is we need to control how we speak, the word we use and the tone when we talk to someone older like our parent, because we never know when the time they will leave us and make we regret it so much.
From the shortfilm, there is too many remainder that useful to us. Thats all from me.
[DANIAL M4T4]
In my point of view, the story is really related to our daily life, like it happened in real life. It's about one whole big family there is a son or daughter who feels being left out and feels they are treated in a different way compared to the other siblings. From the story Tak Pernah Suka Mak, Helmi feels that his mother always ignored his achievements such he had being appointed as a school prefect. But otherwise, his mom adores his brother so much to be the next Ustaz. Even when Helmi got hit by his brother his mom act as if nothing happened. Eventually, the ending is out of the. While Helmi is kept throwing hate at his mom's graveyard suddenly his brother comes and tells him the fact that their mom really loves Helmi so much. Every single night his mom would pray for Helmi and actually did cry in happiness when Helmi got appointed to be the school prefect but his mom just hid the feelings. The moral of the story is that parents should be fair to their kids and treat them equally to make sure none of them feel abandoned and also the kid don't judge their parents too much cause it's their way of hiding their feelings but we'll never know deep down inside their feeling towards us.
The short film "TAK PERNAH SUKA MAK" is a sad film. The main character, Helmi felt like his mother is being ignorant about him. The start of the film, Helmi was found stealing a chicken by his mother, and his mother beat him for that. For me, it is not necessary to beat a child for that but should be given advice not to do that. From the film, it doesnt show that the mother give advice hence she went straight to be mad at her son. One day, villangers come out to their house asking Helmi's brother to teach him a lesson not to steal from them. They went off limit by saying things about their mother. That add the fire to the brother and he decided to beat up Helmi for the villangers. They felt uncomfortable and went back to their houses after some time. If i put myself in Helmi's place, i would feel ashamed and rage because my brother decide to side with others rather than talk to me. It is unnecessary to beat up a sibling in front of others. Next, Helmi showed his mother that he became a prefect, yet his mother looks like uninterested. This really hurt my heart because as the video show, Helmi's look super down after his mother ignored him. When we feel excited to talk to someone about anything it is really hurt mentally when someone doesn't show the same interest. One day, his brother in law take him from school, telling him his mother has passed away. That really hit the nerve because after all things, she is still his mother. Helmi vented to his mother's grave about everything. He wanted to brag about his achievements but its already too late for that. His brother then come to tell him that their mother actually was always care about him. She proud of his achievements, never stop praying for him and even scolded the brother for beating him. Helmi felt ashamed that he doesn't get to hug his mother and havent get to spend precious time with his mother. My conclusion is, no matter how much life hurt, never get mad at your mother. Mother always hold a special place in our heart. She raised us since little. Nothing can compared to a mother's love. At the end of the day, we should always apologise to our mother for our bad behaviour throughout the day. Never hold grudges to our mom, because we never know when is our last time seeing our mother.
Fazrul Amin M5T5
Hi all, I'm here to give my review on a video called "Tak Pernah Suka Mak." All I can say about this video is fantastic. All the actors are well-known in our country and also professional in their job. They have done an amazing job since it feels very real and emotional. The plot twist makes the storyline turn into a masterpiece. I can give it a solid 5 out of 5 since it has a perfect combination. The choreography, lighting, and other elements really showcase its quality. The relationships between family members really have a positive impact on the audience. Therefore, I highly recommend this for everyone to watch and benefit from.
MUHAMMAD AFDHAL IFWAT BIN NOR AZMAN | M4T4
To sum up this short video, the main character, El-Azman, is a daughter who feels unloved by his mother because he thinks his mother is more caring and takes care of other siblings compared to him. El-Azman feel marginalized because his mother does not care what he gets and not appreciate what he receives . One day,when El-Azman was back from school, His brother-in-law took him from school and told him his mother had died. After El-Azman succeeded in his business career, He got to the graveyard of her mother and talked about how he felt when he was little. After that,his brother greets El-Azman and tells a real story about how his mother is caring for him, but in silence. The lesson I get from this short video is that parents must be responsible, mature, and wise in educating their daughters to make sure they do not feel unloved and hate their own parents.
The film left me feeling devastated and sobbing. The main character only wanted his mother to be proud of him. So,he did everything he can just to get his a sliver of his mother's attention. Sadly, his mother was not good at expressing her feelings and therefore kept it all to herself, therefore unable to tell her son anything. Consequently, the son angrily thinks that the mother does not love him . Thankfully, his brother told him that his mother is actually very proud of him. All in all,this short film is a great exploration of grief and the lingering thought of everyone has their own little secrets that they can't tell others whether good or bad.
For me, the short film 'Tak Pernah Suka Mak' was very heartbreaking. Helmi, a child who desired attention from his mother, was constantly neglected by her. Helmi used to cause trouble in the past, which made his mother angry. Although Helmi had changed for the better, his mother never showed any pride in his achievements. On the other hand, his siblings received attention and affection, leaving Helmi feeling neglected by his mother. Helmi harbored a deep resentment towards her. Therefore, as parents, we need to show equal love and attention to all our children.
Nur Farzana Izzati- M5T5
As a person who also didn’t get along well with her parents, I really can relate to it. Sometimes I also want to have a good bond with my parents, like other friends, but what can I do since they are always busy with their work. But I believe the love of a mother will never have an ending. Sometimes mothers don’t show their love through a conversation or action like western families, they always have their own way to protect their children.
My favourite scene is when Zahar is mad at the villagers right after they say that her mother’s fault made his brother become like that. This scene shows the love of a son for his mother by giving her protection. I feel deeply moved by his action because he had the courage to protect his mother and family from getting into trouble.
The scene when Zahar told Helmi the truth about his mother made me not hold back my tears anymore. Finally, the truth had been revealed. Unfortunately, it is too late since his mother has already died.
(Hazwani, C2T2)
After watching this movie, I was deeply moved. The protagonist, Helmi, constantly finds himself at odds with the villagers, and even his own brother, who tries to teach him a lesson but goes about it the wrong way. Helmi feels unloved by his mother, only to discover after her passing that she cherished him deeply. His anguish and longing for his mother are growing even more as he visits her grave, yearning for her embrace. This poignant portrayal underscores the importance of respecting and cherishing our mothers, regardless of their flaws. Mothers should treat their children equally to prevent feelings of neglect. This short film resonated with me deeply, showing powerful emotions about the family dynamics complexity."
Nur Shafika (C2T2)
Mother's love knows no bounds.
From this story, I learned a lot of lessons. First, as a mother she should love her children equally. This to make sure that no one feels offended. But from this ‘Tak pernah suka mak’ film, I can see that Helmi actually misunderstood that his mother doesn’t love him. But it’s actually turns out that his mother doesn’t express her love for him. By this, we can learn that communication between family members is really important and plays a crucial role in order to create a harmonious family.
The main character in the short film 'Tak Pernah Suka Mak' Helmi seems like he was having a hard time living with his mother and brother. This short film shows the biased treatment that Helmi's mom gave to gim. He looks very frustrated and questioning everything that happened back when his mother was still alive. When his brother comes and explain everything that really happened, he realized how his mother loves him so much.
However, I really think that any parents should not behave like this. It is true that every mother will love and care for their children. But sometimes, it should be expressed because it will make the son or daughter feels like being treated poorly.
But I cannot deny that this short film brings a huge meaning to the viewers and the person in the real story, El Azman. He definitely have been through a lot of tough times until he can be what he is now.
To sum up, I can give a 4.7 out of 5 stars because the production and the plotting of the short film was very detailed and does not look messy. The message that they were trying to share is very clear.
HAFIZ ZIKRIE (M4T4)
Helmi as a main character looks like he was having a hard time with his family especially his mother. This short film shows that Helmi’s mother treat he and his brother in very unfair treatment. He was very dissapointed being treat like that when his mother was still alive. Untill one day his brother explain the truth why their mother behave like that, and he realized how much his mother loves him. In my opinion, i totally disagree when there is any parents that behave like this towards their children. I know that most of the mother in the world loves snd cares about their children but sometimes this behavior which is the biased treatment for the children can deeply effect their heart. In a nutshell, i could not deny that this films brings a lot of lesson especially for all of mother out there.
This short film starts with a man saying that he doesn’t like his mother — right in front of her grave!
It really shocked me as I would never expect the beginning to be that vulgar.
Moving on, it shows how his mother interacts with him when he was little. She rarely shows affection towards him, even after he got elected as a prefect in his school. Despite his achievement, his mother gave him the silent treatment, which was unexpecting of a mother whose son that shows potential to be a future leader.
He continues to ramble about what his mother did until his brother showed up. His brother thought that it was time the man knew the truth The truth is that his mother never stopped thinking about him and his name was always brought up in her prayers. This was such a touching moment for me as I always asked my mother to pray for me.
Amir Farhan C2T2
The introduction of this short film made me shock, why does he say that? so i would like to know more about this short film so i decided to watch more to know the truth.
After that, the brother tell everything what happen to him in front of the mother's graveyard. One by one, he explain everything why he do not love his mom. Some of the story is he stole the neighbour's chicken and got hit by his brother, got to be school prefect but the mom does not care, his mom chat normally with the others siblings but to him its different. One day, he wants to go to school but before that he get anger with his mom because its too much. Suddenly when he wants to go back to home from school, he got the news his mother passed away. It was so sad and almost made me tear up. So at the end of the story, his brother came to him and tell the truth, actually the mother love him so much but did not show the truely love. He cried and tell his brother that he wants to feel the mother's hug but now it's gone.
As a conclusion, mother must show love to all her children to make sure that they can feel the love from the parents.
Amir muhd C2T2
In Conteng short movie,Wan is a character that are very loves to draw and he was very talented.But,his father does not support his drawing talent and always mad and yells at him.His father always ask him to leave what he likes to do and focus his study and follow path like his brother and sister to become successful person.One day,he leaves home because he felt upset for his father after after an argument.After that,he becomes successful person as drawing artist and become boss in his own company.One days,his young brother come to work for his company and wan suddenly recognize him a day by day.I am very touching at scene when he call his young brother and hug him also when wanback his home and meet his father.This story teach me that even your family does not support your dream, it is okay to continue it but make sure the dream become true.We should always loves our family.
In this film,Helmi was kind children that always want his mother attention.But sadly, his mother doesn't show loves to Helmi but not for his other sibling make Helmi felt he was ignored.I understand why he started to make problem at village and people always doesn't like him.After that,I feel sad when I see Helmi spread out his feeling to his mother's grave.I also shocked when I know the true story about his mother always loves him after his brother tell him.In this story,I think the mother should give attention and love to his children so the children will not feel ignored.The children also need to think positive to our parent that they always loves their children.
Muhammad Mifzal said
First,The video taught me that as a mother she should equally love all of her children. She can show her love and affectionate to all of his children but not toward helmi. She should not discriminate and care for her children base on their attitiude and behaviour. Even though they might do some wrong , but she as a mother should treat her children equally. Secondly, helmi shouldn’t go and steal other people belongings.
MUHAMMAD HUSAINI C2T2
In my point of view, the story is really related to our daily life, like it happened in real life. It's about one whole big family there is a son or daughter who feels being left out and feels they are treated in a different way compared to the other siblings.
As mothers, we are entrusted with the immense responsibility of shaping the future generation. Our actions and words hold the power to influence the beliefs and values our children carry into adulthood. By embodying fairness and love in our parenting approach, we model essential life lessons of empathy, respect, and kindness.
In conclusion, as mothers, let us strive to treat our children with fairness and love, nurturing their growth and fostering bonds that withstand the test of time. By embodying these principles, we create a legacy of compassion and strength, shaping a brighter and more equitable future for generations to come.
Assalammualaikum, I'm Nuha Bariezah Binti Azahari from C2T2. This is my short review of the story "Tak Pernah Suka Mak".
The short film "Tak Pernah Suka Mak" paints a vivid picture of complex family dynamics, highlighting the pain and misunderstandings that can occur within families. It captures how unaddressed emotions such as stemming from frustration, anger, or disappointment can forge a long-lasting regrets. At its core, the film is a plea for empathy, forgiveness, and the acknowledgment of the unconditional love that often defines the relationship between a child and their mother. Through Helmi's emotional evolution which from feeling overlooked to recognizing his mother's silent support, the narrative invites reflection on missed opportunities for reconciliation and the critical need for expressing love and gratitude freely and frequently.
The film serves as a emotional reminder of the power of forgiveness, the depth of a mother's love, and the dangers of letting misunderstandings fester. It's a call to action for more empathy and open-hearted communication in our relationships, especially with those who mean the most to us.
In my point of view, "Tak Pernah Suka Mak" delivered the message well as it always happened in our society.
This shortfilm was set up where the main character,Helmi is a naughty yet kind son. He always creates problems that made people mad on him and his family. His mom already annoyed with his temperament.
His mom always treat the other siblings in a good mood unlike him. This made Helmi feel unloved by his mom. Until one day, after going back from school he got to know that his mom had passed away. He felt disappointed as he couldn't receive enough attention and love from his mom. His brother said that mom never annoyed with him, its just mom doesn't show it. Mom always proud of Helmi as he achieved to be leader in school, mom never skipped to pray on him.
"Tak Pernah Suka Mak" shows a lot of things that we could learn from. As a mom , she should not treat Helmi in that way instead give all the children love equally. Mom should show their love openly to avoid misunderstood upon children.
Tak Pernah Suka Mak is a short eid film based on a true story of the Elrah’s founder, Hilmi. It is a sad story that shows how he was treated by his late mother. This short film went viral among Malaysian.
After I watched the film, I actually sat silently in front of the screen for a couple of minutes. The sense of powerlessness surrounded me and trapped me inside. Not because the film is sad, but because it is literally based on a true story.
The only idea that crossed my mind after I watched the film is “why does his mother awfully treated him?”. The feeling of disgust raised every time the scene showing how Hilmi got treated. A scene where his mother helps Hilmi’s brother to pack his things meanwhile Hilmi has to pack all his clothes by himself was a scene that sticks on my head.
At the end of the film, Hilmi’s older brother explained all of the misunderstandings. Hilmi's mother never intended to treat Hilmi cruelly, even though Hilmi was the child she always prayed for. His mother always cares about him without he realises.
In conclusion, I think this is a great short film which shows parenting elements. There is plenty of lessons that can be learned in this film for example, parents should express love to their children so they not feeling ignored.
Deevesh, E3T3
This short film is very heart-touching and explains to us about a mother's love. This film is very relatable to the generation today where not many understand the love of a mother and ignore their mothers at one point.
From this short film, we can say that no one in this world has the right to doubt a mother's love no matter how they have treated you, a mother will always love each of their children fairly.
On the other hand, some might say that she should a mother hide their feelings towards their children, it is because they are afraid that too much praising would make you arrogant or stop being hungry for more success but no matter what it is she always believes that you can do more. She will always be proud of you.
In my opinion, this is a good film that every teenager today should watch and learn to appreciate their mothers because not everyone is gonna live forever and it will be too late to regret it later on.
MUHAMMAD AMIR HAKIM BIN ABU BAKAR M5T5
The story "Tak Pernah Suka Mak" begins with Helmi visiting his late mother's grave. At his mother's grave, he said something that was really inappropriate. "I never loved you," he said. What had his mother said until he could say words like that? The story starts by flashbacking to his past.
In the past, Helmi was known as a naughty boy and liked to steal things like chickens. He got caught by his mother and punished. Some of the punishments he got were too heavy and inappropriate for him.
The story continues with his opportunities to become prefect. He went to his mother to share this proud and happy moment. Unfortunately, his mother did not give any reaction, and this really makes him very disappointed. Besides that, his mother likes to ignore him and more particularly his siblings. This made Helmi so mad at his mother. Later on, back from his camp, he received sad news: his mother is dead. He couldn't believe it.
Back to the present, he still cannot forgive his mother for all the things that she has done. However, his older brother showed up and told all the truth about their mother. Helmi's mother never ignores him and always cares about him. She hid her true feelings and never showed up her love for Helmi. She also always mentions Helmi in her prayers. After hearing the truth, Helmi felt very sad and wanted to hug his mother so much, but he couldn't and never could.
From this story, we can conclude that it is important for us to show our care and love to our family members or beloved ones. Sometimes they can't see our care for them, and this will make them feel lonely and unloved. So, stop pretending that you do not love them, but show your love and care to help them become better and better.
afdal fahmi E3T3
In this short film, I learned some new lessons. Firstly, as parents who aim to instill positive attitudes in our children, it's important to express love to each child to avoid them feeling neglected. Failing to do so may lead to experiences similar to those depicted in the film. While it's necessary to be firm in parenting to prevent them from engaging in harmful behaviors that could impact their future, it's equally important to show affection. Secondly, as children, we should always appreciate our parents, even if they lack certain parenting skills. Parents may take pride in our achievements but may struggle to express it. We shouldn't dwell on this; instead, we should continue to do good deeds and repay their dedication to raising us since childhood.
That concludes my thoughts.Thankyou.
HAIKAL
E3T3
This short film really touching my heart.In this short film show that "Mi" is always ignore by his mother.His mother act like he didnt care about him but his mother actually care about him.It really sad because that what happen in reality nowadays.
In this short film I learned a lot of thing.Firstly,It important to express love to our child to avoid miscommunication.Secondly, we need to show respect to our parent because they are the on who raised us.In conclussion, this short film have a deep massage. Overall i will rate this short film 9/10
Muhammad Abdul Karim bin Abdul Halim
E3T3
Assalamualaikum and Hi everyone , I want to review a short film titled "Tak Pernah Suka Mak". This film is inspired by a true story about the life of the founder of baju melayu branded Elrah exclusive. This story is very sad about a character named Helmi who is often not treated by his mother. His mother always exaggerates and makes his other brothers proud. Helmi felt angry and very sad because his mother did not treat him like his other brothers. Because of this, he became a mischievous person. He stole people's chickens and was scolded by his mother. His brother also beat him badly. One day, when he returned home, his brother-in-law picked him up from school and said that his mother had died. Helmi felt very sad. In the end, Helmi became a successful person and had everything but he did not have a mother's love. Then, his brother came to him and told him that their mother never did not love Helmi. Their mother always cares about Helmi and prays for her children, especially Helmi. Helmi felt very sad and cried. From this story we can learn to always do good to our parents even if they do bad things to us. In addition, we as parents should be fair to our children so that they can feel the love of their parents and become excellent human beings.
Tak Pernah Suka Mak (review)
When it comes to family issue, it will always catch my attention no matter how small it is, and this short film included just that. Started with a scene of a man; named Helmi, visiting his mother's grave. The first thing he said is literally the title itself; 'Tak pernah suka mak.'
The storyline is basically Helmi refreshing his old memories during his bad childhood. It might sounds simple, but it leads to thousands of meaning. As an example, there is this one time when Helmi got a promotion to be a school prefect, but when he told his mother, the reaction is no less than an emotionless face, and this made Helmi so mad and so sad that he raised his voice to his mother telling her that he is nothing to her, he is not good and so on.
Later, at the end of his schoolday, when he got up in the car, he was told that his mother was gone. Died, just like that. Helmi got not much reaction that time other than asking why his mother left him just like that. He said it was so unfair, after all that has happened, after all the love that he can't get, after all of the argument; why, his mother left like nothing happened.
The story continues, Helmi keep talking at the grave, saying that he can get everything he wants now, except one thing. One thing that he always dreamed to do, to see, and to feel; he wanted to hug his mother once again. To be honest among all other parts, this part got me the most. It was an instant cry for me. This part really made me regret the way I treat my mother all this time.
Last but not least, I can say three things about this short film. Firstly, this short film was very well-made, the storyline was good and the characters really lived in the film. Secondly, it was very impactful, that I have not stop thinking about how I treat my mother all this time. Thirdly, this short film is one of the best short film I have ever watched in my entire life. That's all I can say!
I’m Harith B5T5 ….From the short video, the main character, a man is a daughter who feels unloved by his mother because he thinks his mother is more cared to other siblings compared to him. One day,when the man was back from school, His brother-in-law took him from school and told him his mother had died. After the man succeeded in his business career, He got to the his brother of her mother and talked about how he felt when he was little. After that,his brother greets the man and tells a real story about how his mother is caring for him, but in silence.
Finally, the truth had been revealed. Unfortunately, it is too late since his mother has already died. The lesson I get from this short video is that parents must be responsible, mature, and wise in educating their daughters to make sure they do not feel unloved and hate their own parents.
Assalamualaikum and hi,I'm Shamsul Mu'izz Mukhriz Bin Shamsul Bakri from class E3T3.
I want to review about this short film
First of all this short film told about a boy named 'Mi' that felt hatred to his mom.This story start with 'Mi' stole a chicken and was beaten by his brother because he stole the chicken.He also felt hate because the treatment he get is difference from his other brother.He feel that his mom doesn't love him as much as his other siblings.One day his brother-in-law take him from school and told him not to be sad because their mom has passed away.Many year has gone by and he has become a successful man.He visited his mother grave and told how he was doing and that he doesn't like his mom.Then his brother came and tell him how much their mom love 'Mi' secretly.His mom always pray for him to became a successful person.'Mi' felt sad because he had achieved all the thing he wanted but one thing he can't get when he is successful is to hug his mother.
From this short film i can conclude that we must spend more time with parents while there are alive so you won't regret it later.As a parent also we have to show a fair treatment to all of our children ao that they felt appreciate and greatful.Lastly I can tell that too much hatred will give you uncomfortable live style because you will felt with guilty.
MUHAMMAD IQMAL HAKIM BIN NASARUDIN E3T3
This story tells about parents who are partial to their children.
If we follow the story of Prophet Yusuf a.s., he was hated by his brothers and sisters until they agreed to harm Yusu f. Because of what? Because of envy and consumed by the devil's incitement against the way their father Prophet Jacob treated Yusuf. Other brothers and sisters feel that this person is not treated like a child, so they want to get rid of them. See how emotional and hasty thinking can lead to bad things. Yusuf's siblings even called their father crazy, because they overestimated Yusuf. If you all read the orientalist comments, the old father's attitude they call choosing love, unfair parenting. Does the prophet behave like that? Aren't they guided by revelation? So what do we fail to understand here? That, parents read character, soul, children. The superior, the independent, the strong less attention. The weak, those who need more treatment, those who need guidance, the small ones are given more focus. This is justice. Justice is not all equal, but given according to need. In the perception that Elrah is trying to highlight, the sister is more focused. My brother is prayed for at three o'clock in the night. If we follow the emotional narrative in this gift, not rational, we will find 1001 mistakes of our elders. While they are fighting desperately in all those shortcomings to raise the level of children a little higher than them. Forgive our parents while they are still alive in the world.
Im iffah from B5T5 ,My honest review about his short film is very heart-touching and explains to us about a mother's love. This film is very relatable to the generation today where not many understand the love of a mother and ignore their mothers at one point.
On the other hand, some might say that she should a mother hide their feelings towards their children, it is because they are afraid that too much praising would make you arrogant or stop being hungry for more success but no matter what it is she always believes that you can do more. She will always be proud of you.
In my opinion, this is a good film that every teenager today should watch and learn to appreciate their mothers because not everyone is gonna live forever and it will be too late to regret it later on.
What I understand about the situation in this video, Helmi was a mischievous, evil type when he was little, he liked to steal things from the villagers until one village claimed he liked to steal people's things. That's what his mother treats Helmi firmly and harshly compared to other siblings, more gentle and caring.
But when Helmi has slowly improved and is better until he can become a supervisor, his mother still scolds him because of his naughty behavior before. Although far away in the corner of her heart, she still loves him and hopes that things will get better. That's the one who always prays, but her mother's mistake is not showing her love and concern for Helmi until Helmi holds a grudge against her mother.
It's just that when his brother comes to tell the truth, it's too late, until at some point he can't feel his mother's love in reality and face to face.
The lesson is, it doesn't matter if it's parents or children, as long as you have the opportunity to love, do it. Don't let it be gone, regret it.
LUQMAN E3T3
The video is set at a graveyard with the main character going to his mother's grave and recollecting some memories of them together. At first, the memories he had of his mother was in his perspective, awful. His mom ignoring his achievements, cruel punishments and giving more priority to his siblings. During the recollection of memories, we can hear the main character narrating. The way he worded his sentences were both form of resentment and questions. "Why would my mother do this to me?" is the vibe I'm getting from. I though it was just another case of bad parenting but then, the main character's brother shows up and reveals the truth. His mom was proud of him and prayed for his success the most. As the brother reveal the truth bit by bit, the resentment withing the main character was actually false. It was love that he had for his mother. Unconditional love from the very beginning. As he breaks into tears with his brother, we can see the mask finally break, revealing the true love of a family within them.
Azri E3T3
About this short film, the tale was about a person named helmi who has a hatred feeling on his mother. He hate his mother because of how she treat him harmfully that his other brother.Helmi like to steal things from the fellows villagers. After his mother passed away, he came to his mother grave to show his feelings to her but his older brother came to him tell out the truths about his mother. She always take acting to his brothers that treat him badly and always felt grateful for his success . Helmi hug his brother crying and hoping to see his mother and hugging her for the last time. From this story, the message give us a positive mindset about our parents and feel grateful to them. We cannot feel and hatred feeling on them instead always have the feeling of love at them. For this short film, i gave it 9.5 out of ten because it made me cry and the message it delivered to my heart. I hope this type of film will be continually produced so that teenagers feel grateful to their parents.
From
Azri Firdaus E3T3
CHEAH YOONG CHUIN B5T5
Welcome to my review of 'Tak Pernah Suka Mak,' a touching film that explores the complexities of familial relationships and forgiveness. This Malaysian drama takes viewers on an emotional rollercoaster filled with heartwarming moments and poignant reflections.
At its core, 'Tak Pernah Suka Mak' explores themes of forgiveness, redemption, and the importance of familial bonds. Through the tumultuous relationship between Mak and Helmi , the film reminds viewers of the transformative power of forgiveness and the healing that comes from letting go of past grievances. It also underscores the significance of communication and empathy in rebuilding fractured relationships.
In conclusion, 'Tak Pernah Suka Mak' is a poignant and thought-provoking film that resonates long after the credits roll. With its compelling performances, heartfelt storytelling, and universal themes, it is a must-watch for anyone who appreciates powerful narratives about love, forgiveness, and the intricacies of family dynamics
Short Video Review - Tak Pernah Suka Mak
"Tak Pernah Suka Mak" is a short film that explores the story of a family's relationships, a mother, and son, Helmi. Helmi is a man who visits his mother's grave retaining a deep resentment. He blames her mother for a forsaken childhood, filled with loneliness, helpless.
The story goes back in time to show Helmi as a boy. He got into trouble and feels like his mom never give attention towards him. Even when he did something good, for example, becoming a school leader, her reaction remains cold. This caused Helmi fuels his anger and makes him rebel.
Tragedy strikes when Helmi's mother unexpectedly died. Later, he visited his mom's grave, he pour every single dissatisfaction in childhood that how his mother treated him at the graveyard. By then, he met his elder brother, and yet he realise the truth from his brother that his mom actually did love him a lot, she just didn't express it out the way Helmi expect. She always pray for him and was proud of his achievements, even she never show it to Helmi.
This film's core lies in Helmi's heartbreaking realisation. He has achieved success in life, but he one thing he craves the most, a mother's love, is now a forever lost. The simple act of hugging his mother had became a symbol of love which he will never received and the regret he will carry onward...
KOK QI SHENG
E3T3
It’s about how important it is for all of us kids to feel loved and important, no matter who we are. We should always show kindness and love to everyone equally. It’s like, everyone gets a slice of the cake, so no one ends up hungry or sad. This means that no one gets left out or feels less special than anyone else.So, let’s all remember to be fair and share love and kindness with each other. It’s not just about being nice; it’s about making sure everyone feels like they belong. That’s the lesson I learned today, and I think it’s a pretty important one.
In my opinion, "Tak Pernah Suka Mak" effectively expressed the message, as it always does in our society.The main character, Helmi, is a naughty but nice son in this short film. He is constantly causing problems that upset others towards him and his family. His mother was already frustrated with his temperament.
In contrast to him, his mother always treats his siblings positively. This made Helmi feel unloved by his mother. Until one day, after returning from school, he learned that his mother had died. He was disappointed since he couldn't get enough attention and love from his mother. His brother stated that mum is never annoyed with him; it is simply that she does not show it. Mom was always proud of Helmi for becoming a school leader, and she never stopped praying for him. "Tak Pernah Suka Mak" provides a wealth of knowledge that is applicable to us. She should to love all the kids equally as a mother and not treat Helmi that way. Moms should be transparent in their love to prevent children from incorrectly understanding them.
The short video 'Tak pernah suka mak' was a heart touching video that show the complexities of a mother-son relationship. From the video we can see how parenting can affect the children characters and behavior. I think we can say that parent should show affection to their children equally so that they feel loved. From the video Helmi though his mother didn't love him because she always scold him and didn't care about his achievement so Helmi become rebellious and do bad thing. Helmi end up hating his mom even after she passed away until his brother tell him how much their mom love him and what she did for him. Helmi regret that he can't hug his mom anymore. This show that parents love is important for children so that they know there is someone who love them and support them to achieve their dream and this can make children more confident and ambitious .
Lim Ching Suen B5T5
This video is about Mi, a guy that thought that his mother never loved him before and always care for other siblings more. This makes him hated his mother even until his mother passed away. Later when he visited his mother's grave, his brother reveal how deep actually his mother loved him and always hope the best for him. He regretted instantly for being so mean to her mother and wish he could get a hug from his mother again but we all know his dream will never come true.
This video shows the importance of parents expressing their love to their children directly as not all children understand the good intentions of their parents. This will end up cause misunderstanding between parents and children. Consequently, this action loose the relationship bond between parents and their children until estrangement happens.
Post a Comment